He took a frayed hat from his head, And â€œPeace on Earthâ€ was what he said. â€œA morsel out of what youâ€™re worth, And there we have it: Peace on Earth. Not much, although a little more Than what there was on earth before Iâ€™m as you see, Iâ€™m Ichabod,â€” But never mind the ways Iâ€™ve trod; Iâ€™m sober now, so help me God.â€
I could not pass the fellow by. â€œDo you believe in God?â€ said I; â€œAnd is there to be Peace on Earth?â€
â€œTonight we celebrate the birth,â€ He said, â€œof One who died for men; The Son of God, we say. What then? Your God, or mine? Iâ€™d make you laugh Were I to tell you even half That I have learned of mine today Where yours would hardly seem to stay. Could He but follow in and out Some anthropoids I know about, The god to whom you may have prayed Might see a world He never made.â€
â€œYour words are flowing full,â€ said I; â€œBut yet they give me no reply; Your fountain might as well be dry.â€
â€œA wiser One than you, my friend, Would wait and hear me to the end; And for his eyes a light would shine Through this unpleasant shell of mine That in your fancy makes of me A Christmas curiosity. All right, I might be worse than that; And you might now be lying flat; I might have done it from behind, And taken what there was to find. Donâ€™t worry, for Iâ€™m not that kind. â€˜Do I believe in God?â€™ Is that The price tonight of a new hat? Has he commanded that his name Be written everywhere the same? Have all who live in every place Identified his hidden face? Who knows but he may like as well My story as one you may tell? And if he show me there be Peace On Earth, as there be fields and trees Outside a jail-yard, am I wrong If now I sing him a new song? Your world is in yourself, my friend, For your endurance to the end; And all the Peace there is on Earth Is faith in what your world is worth, And saying, without any lies, Your world could not be otherwise.â€
â€œOne might say that and then be shot,â€ I told him; and he said: â€œWhy not?â€ I ceased, and gave him rather more Than he was counting of my store. â€œAnd since I have it, thanks to you, Donâ€™t ask me what I mean to do,â€ Said he. â€œBelieve that even I Would rather tell the truth than lieâ€” On Christmas Eve. No matter why.â€
His unshaved, educated face, His inextinguishable grace. And his hard smile, are with me still, Deplore the vision as I will; For whatsoever he be at, So droll a derelict as that Should have at least another hat.